Co-Parenting Divorce Single Motherhood
November 30th, 2017
How To Talk To Your Child About An Absent Father
Recently an anonymous reader asked:
My son often asks for his daddy. I don’t know what to say to him. It breaks my heart because I’ve done everything I can to bridge the gap and encourage his father to be a part of his life. But he’s totally absent. Only visits maybe 20hrs a month sometimes less. Can you give me any advice on what to say to my son about where his father is? Why he isn’t here etc?
First of all, let me say that these kinds of questions break my heart. According to Psychology today, “…24 million children live in biological father-absent homes—in the United States alone. And 1 in 3 children grow up without a father.” What this means first and foremost is that you are not alone.
Here are some top-tips for handling these questions, some of which depend on age and development, but most of which can apply:
- Answer all questions simply and generally. Don’t give too much detail, or infuse your own thoughts and feelings into your answers. Deborah Roth Ledley, PhD, licensed psychologist advises: “A child’s worries and thoughts are much simpler than ours and the last thing we want to do is start projecting our own worries and negative thoughts onto them. So, when very young children ask questions about their absent parent, try to be very simple and general. Something like, “Sometimes mommies and daddies don’t get along well and they decide that everyone will be happier if they live apart,” or “Some kids live with their mom and dad, or just their mom, or their grandma. Families are all different.” Then, ask the child for their follow-up questions. As the child grows, the discussion will too — one day at a time.” (Psychology Today)
- Never speak ill of the other parent. Sticking to the basic facts of why he’s not there is a good idea, but you may have to fudge them slightly so as not to throw dad under the bus. You’ll want to tell the truth, but always speak kindly about the absent dad. As time goes on, your child will begin to draw their own conclusions based on their own observations. You may want to write out some stock answers so you’re well-prepared in the moment, as it might be hard for you to come up with answers that aren’t infused with your own anger and sadness in the moment. While your feelings are entirely valid, you don’t want to put them onto your child.
- Always validate their feelings. When they tell you their feelings, don’t try to minimize them or take them away. Make sure you tell your child that it’s ok for them to feel sad or mad. Validation is as simple as mirroring: “I know it’s hard,” “You really miss your dad. I miss him too sometimes,” “I can see that you’re really angry; I feel angry too sometimes.”
- Reiterate that it’s not their fault. Because children are all self-referential thinkers (they naturally think the world revolves around them), they will assume their father’s absence is because of them. Michael Gurian (the insightful best selling author of “The Wonder Of Boys” and “The Wonder Of Girls”) stresses the importance of reassuring the child they’re not at fault, saying: “First and foremost, a child who is abandoned must be constantly and repetitively told (and convinced) that s/he was not at fault for the abandonment. This can take months and years of repetition—gentle, firm, clear, loving—with realistic dialogue about exactly why the father left so that the child can see that the child was not causal of the abandonment.” (Parenting.com) In addition, be sure to affirm your child’s great qualities and value as often as possible by encouraging and praising good behavior, rather than disciplining bad behavior. They’ll need the extra boost of confidence this will provide.
- Make a list of the dad’s good qualities. If a child begins to understand that their father has some kind of deficiency (for lack of a better word) that allows them to not show up for their child, they may begin to wonder what that might mean about them, genetically speaking. (“If my dad has no conscience, does that mean I won’t?”) Listing their father’s good qualities will enforce their feelings that they come from “good stock,” while also creating space for the father to step back in, should they have a change of heart down the line.
- Identify father figures in their life now. Be sure your child is surrounded by at least one father-figure that you can call upon in times of need, such as Father’s Day, or a dad-day at school, or a time when you think a father-figure might be most appropriate for working through a problem. Sometimes our sons in particular don’t want to talk to us moms about certain things, so having someone on call to take him out for ice cream for some dude-time can help provide them with an outlet.
Hopefully this will help you navigate through some of these really tricky waters. Remember, your son is lucky to have your unconditional love and support, and you are enough for him. Some incredibly successful people in our society have been raised by single moms: Barack Obama, Michael Phelps, Jay Z, Jon Stewart, and many more. They all attribute their success and world-view to the mothers who raised them alone.
For more information on healthy co-parenting in divorce, check out The Divorce Survival Program.
Thank you for this. I needed this tonight. My daughter will be 7 in July, and her dad has been in and out of jail/prison for most of her life already, and she is extremely hurt and confused and wondering why he isn’t here. We are almost divorced as well so it’s been hard. Tonight I find myself crying after I just got her to sleep because I’m tired and emotionally exhausted. It’s good to know I’m not alone and it’s great to have these tips on how to navigate all of this. Thank you.
I’m so sorry you’re going through this. It’s so hard. I’m glad your daughter has you as her solid rock. That will be everything to her.
I am pregnant and not planning to disclose who the father is to people or to my unborn child due to certain circumstances but I have a 9 year old who’s got a father(The father will be present but no one will know that he’s the biological dad).. Yes I know it sounds bizzare. And am worried it will confuse her as she will automatically think that they share same father and wonder why they don’t and why baby has got no father. How can I best handle this situation, please any advise would be appreciated. And am also worried that both my kids might get affected in long run.
This sounds very complicated and not something I can advise on without knowing more details. My best advise would be to get a child therapist involved.
Sharon,
I do not know your personal situation but keeping who your childrens fathers are from them will most certainly affect them in the long run. Regardless of what their fathers have done, they have a part of their DNA and at least deserve to know who helped conceive them. They are a part of their identity. If you don’t believe me, speak with a child psychologist. Good Luck.
I have been going through this for the last couple years with my 7 soon to be 8 year old. She asks randomly why her dad doesn’t come around or how come I get to see my father and other kids do as well. It is very tough. I try to keep it simple and like mentioned above don’t point any fingers. I hope just constant reassurance that she is loved by many and that we all have different “types of families’ will help. One thing I noticed the last time she asked she ended with my dad isn’t a good person. I never mention anything in a negative tone about him. Really shocked me that at 7 years old she is coming up with her own version on who he is as a parent. Best wishes to you all it definitely is a struggle sometimes. Especially when it nears holidays, fathers day etc.
My child is now 9 years old and the hardest words to hear her say is what about me? Her dad has been an inconsistent father since the age of 2 after we separated. He has 2 other children with someone else and my daughter only knows of one sibling because when she met her first sibling and she would ask why her dad did not come to see her I would say it’s because he works hard to provide for diapers for the new baby. I explained to her that they are very expensive so she understood but often said what about me? It’s heartbreaking to look at them in their eyes and not feel their pain. I remind her how much she is loved and how much she has stolen her grandfather’s heart.
I’m so sorry your daughter is going through this. I would advise not saying that her dad isn’t seeing her because he needs to buy diapers for another child. That could make her feel that the new baby is more important, and you don’t ever want to be the one saying that to her. Follow the advice in this article. I wish you all the best. xoxo Kate
My 3 and a half year old, Jack, is in love with his father. We are no longer together but his father still gets him every week for two days. Recently, Jack’s father just decided he didn’t want to do it anymore. He has scrubbed my sweet baby’s memory from his FB, hasn’t called or messaged, and I know he isn’t coming back. Jack talks about him incessantly, he worships the ground he walks on. I have no family, it is just us. The guilt and deep sadness I live with now is immense. I don’t allow it to show but it takes everything inside of me to stifle a sob every time he mentions his daddy. Any advice would be sincerely appreciated. I don’t want Jack to hurt.
This is so awful. I’m so sorry for you, and for poor, sweet Jack. My best advice is in this article. Jack is lucky to have a mom who’s so dedicated and loving. While you can’t be a dad to him, you can be a present, loving mom, which it’s clear you are. xoxo Kate
I’m a mom of a 3 year old and he just started asking about his dad since starting summer camp. He whines and throws tantrums about “where’s my daddy?” And ” I want my daddy”. My heart breaks because his father is incarcerated and our relationship was very toxic even through my pregnancy. It wasn’t until my son was born and the toxicity continued indecided to leave because my son felt the energy.
When he calls my son doesn’t want to talk to him. What am I doing wrong? How can I let my baby know that he has so much love surrounding him? As I write this he just cried himself into a nap asking for his dad. Please help me!
You’re not doing anything wrong. He’s in a really confusing and tough spot. Validate his feelings, and let him know his daddy loves him, but can’t see him in person right now because he had to go away. Let him know that his daddy wants to talk to him on the phone, and that for now that’s the only way he can spend time with him. He should also be in therapy with a child specialist if that’s at all possible.
Grandson is 10. Adores his father but dad only sees him once every 6 to 8 weeks due to his choice to work out of state. He now has 2 other kids with 2 other women. Lives with one of the babies. He calls once every two weeks but conversation only lasts less than 5 minutes. Last visitation weekend we found out dad chose a golf tournament all weekend instead of spending his time with my grandson. He stayed with his aunt.
Grandson has stepfather that is horrible excuse for a father. Grandson is now acting out, arguing, angry, won’t mind etc He has begun breaking down more and more saying he misses his dad and wants to be with him. How do we help him? Stepdad is clueless and thinks he’s not the problem so he won’t change his behavior. This has been addressed several times in the last four years.
Daughter feels stuck having to choose between the two. I say should not be a choice. Her son comes first.
My heart is hurting for him.
My sister’s two kids dad left out of the blue and the truth came out that he had other kids and never told anyone where he was going and all his friends told my sister that they didn’t know anything then turn around and the truth came out and she found out he was with another woman who he had kids with and had other kids with other women and we can’t figure out how to tell my nieces how to tell them their dad isn’t coming back
I have a 4 year old son. His father is completely absent due to drug abuse. I have been in a same sex relationship since he was 6 months old. He has never met his dad and I don’t talk about him. But my son is now asking if he has a dad like his friends. How do I tell him that I kept him from his dad to keep him safe? My partner is the favorite parent so there is no issue with my son having a parent/child relationship with her.
I’d be honest and say that he has a dad but he has a lot of problems and isn’t able to be a father, and that someday you hope that might change. Ask how he feels about that. Keep a dialogue open. You might even have a conversation about addiction and how it’s often not a choice. It’s not that he’s choosing drugs over fatherhood, it’s that the drugs choose for him, and it’s very sad. You can also reinforce the family he does have by saying, “But aren’t we lucky that we have {x} in our family now and that we can be such a strong and happy family.” Keep the lines of communication open.
My almost five year old tonight mentioned her other Dad. Her biological dad and I separated when she was seven weeks old. There was a lot of emotional and financial abuse and he has wrote her off completely. No visitation. No holidays. No phone calls. Nothing. In his mind she doesn’t exist. She named all the members of our family tonight in a story. Starting with her, me, my boyfriend (who plans to adopt her once we get married), then grandparents, and she ends with other dad. Completely caught me off guard since she hasn’t mentioned him. I don’t know how to ask her what she is feeling or thinking. I was dreading the day she mentioned him because I know how much it’s going to hurt her. Any advice on how to completely kid proof this topic?
Simply keep the dialogue open and be curious. Ask her questions, and give her age-appropriate answers. It’s good that she’s talking about it, and you should be as well.
My sons father wanted me to have an abortion, but that did not feel right for me- we split ways when I was 3 months pregnant and he has refused any contact since that day.. My son is now four, he is an outgoing, loving, kind sweet boy. His father to this day has never acknowledged his existence. My son doesn’t yet know anything about his “father”. He believes that my dad, his grandpa is his father and calls him dad sometimes- his grandpa has been there for him since he was an infant and loves him dearly. As he gets older and realizes that my dad is not his real dad, what is the healthiest way to talk to him about this?
My sons father and I were separated the day after our sons 1st birthday. He had packed his stuff and left without a word to live with another woman. I picked up and moved on, but then my sons father wanted to come back in his life. My son is currently 4, and I’ve tried to help foster the relationship between my son and his father, but his father is more focused on himself and making excuses. My sons father always promises to visit him, but has not done so yet. Whenever my son does see his father it’s because I always take the time to bring him to the city his father lives do all the chauffeuring and everything else just so my son can have a safe and decent visit. Ive asked his father to set up phone schedules so that there is consistant communication and he doesn’t follow it. I eventually got tired of being the one to do all the work of supporting their relationship especially when it was so inconsistent for our son. The longest he’s gone of not speaking to our son has been 4 months, but the last recent stretch is 1 month. My son now starts to ask a lot more about his dad, and I try to be honest with him without bringing to much emotion into it. My son loves his father despite the fact he’s barely developed a relationship with him. It is frustrating for me as the single mom to not want to lash out at my sons father for his absenteeism, but I know that his father makes up half of who he is, and it will take time until he fully understands what is going on.
Thank you for your advice to everyone on here! My 8 year old son has never met his father. He’s in active addiction but for 8 years I have tried to reach out to him on Facebook and I send him pictures. He reads the messages but doesn’t respond. My son has always said “I don’t have a dad” if anyone asked and it was more matter of fact than emotional. He wants a dad so badly but never had one so I guess he doesn’t know what he’s missing, he just REALLY wants one. As he’s getting older, and around friends, he’s realizing, kind of asking, that he does have a dad. What’s the best and least harmful way I can talk to him about this? My son is a miracle and the best thing that ever happened to me. He’s so sweet and kind and happy. I don’t want him to hurt!
I have a 5 year old daughter her biological father has seen her 5 times in the first year she was alive and not since. My husband (now) brought my daughter home from the hospital and has always been daddy to her. I have never talked about the bio dad bc I thought he was gone for good.He now wants to see her and I have no clue how to even explain to her who he is .
My ex and I were separated for 9 months and have been divorced for a year now. We have 3 kids together 9, 6,3. It was a toxic relationship and my ex was unfaithful during our marriage. He makes an attempt to see the kids once a month (usually less than 24 hrs) and calls to talk to them about once a month (for five minutes or less usually). He makes no attempt to check in to see how they are doing. The other day my daughter was upset and asked why I don’t let them see their dad. I told her I wasn’t keeping them from their dad, but that their dad wasn’t making any effort to see them. I know that wasn’t the best way to tell my kids that, but it is the truth. What could I have done differently? I tell my kids often that our divorce is not their fault and I remind them daily how much I love them and how important they are to me. I don’t discourage a relationship with their dad, but I am tired of crossing my own boundaries and going out of my way to encourage them that their dad is a good person when he clearly doesn’t care for them or their well being. Help! What do I do?
I’m so sorry you’re going through this. This is a really tough position for you to be in. On the one hand you don’t want to throw their dad under the bus; on the other, you want to be sure they know you’re not the one keeping him from them. It’s so hard to be the parent who sticks around only to be blamed and have your kids be angry at you! I’d be honest and say that people make choices every day in their lives. Sometimes people make good choices; sometimes people make bad choices. Sometimes people make choices that they later regret. Let them know that you know that he loves them, but right now he’s making some bad choices in not choosing to spend time with his children, and that you know that someday he’ll regret this decision. Talk to them about patience and forgiveness. Also let them know that any feelings they have about this are completely valid. They’re allowed to be angry with him. They’re allowed to be sad. Keep an open dialogue with them about their feelings, and make sure they have a therapist or a school counselor they see regularly to help them process their emotions in a neutral environment. Good luck!