Divorce is one of the most emotionally and logistically complex decisions you’ll ever face. And when it comes to navigating the legal aspects, the attorney you choose can significantly impact the outcome of your case—not to mention your stress levels along the way. But how do you know who’s the right fit?

The truth is, not all divorce attorneys are created equal. Some are skilled litigators who thrive in court, while others are settlement-minded and focus on mediation or collaborative law. Your needs will depend on the specifics of your situation—especially if abuse, financial complexity, or child custody issues are in play. That’s why it’s critical to ask the right questions during the consultation process.

Here are some key areas to focus on:

1. Communication is Key

How and how often your attorney communicates with you will make or break your experience. Ask questions like:

• How will we communicate about my case?

   

• Will I be in direct contact with you or mostly with a paralegal?

   

• What’s your usual response time?

   

You’re not just hiring a legal expert—you’re hiring someone to guide you through a deeply personal and vulnerable transition. You need to know they’ll be responsive, clear, and compassionate.

2. Understand the Financials Upfront

Divorce is expensive, but surprise bills make it worse. During your consultation, clarify:

• What is your hourly rate and retainer?

   

• Do you bill for paralegal time at a different rate?

   

• How often will I be billed, and what are the ways I can keep costs down?

   

Also ask how they’ll handle it if your spouse tries to drive up legal fees (a common tactic in high-conflict divorces). And, if applicable, inquire whether your spouse could be ordered to pay your legal fees.

3. Set Realistic Expectations

You need an attorney who tells you the truth—not just what you want to hear. Be sure to ask:

• How long might my divorce take?

   

• What does the typical process look like?

   

• Do you have time to take on my case?

   

• What are the court’s tendencies in cases like mine?

   

Make sure they can answer questions specific to your case, like parenting plans, temporary orders, or financial support estimates.

4. Know Who’s Really Representing You

Sometimes the person you consult with isn’t the one who’ll be in court with you. Ask:

• Who exactly will be working on my case?

   

• If we need to go to court, who will be making appearances?

   

And don’t be afraid to request references. A reputable attorney will understand that you’re making an important decision and should welcome the opportunity to put your mind at ease.

5. Trust Your Gut

All the credentials and experience in the world won’t matter if you don’t feel safe, heard, and respected by your attorney. This person will be your advocate through some of the most vulnerable moments of your life. Pay attention to how you feel during your consultation—do you feel rushed or dismissed? Are your concerns validated? Do they speak down to you or empower you?

Comfort with your representation is just as important as competence. If something feels off, it probably is. Your gut instinct is a powerful tool—don’t ignore it.

Final Thoughts

Choosing a divorce attorney isn’t just about hiring someone with the right credentials—it’s about finding someone you can trust to walk beside you during one of the most vulnerable times in your life. Ask thoughtful, informed questions and don’t be afraid to interview multiple attorneys before making your choice.

Need more help preparing? Grab my divorce planner + resources bundle here